Girl Clown Dancing
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

Getting Snookered

3/14/2015

36 Comments

 
Picture
Growing up, my brother and I always had what we needed.  But there wasn’t a lot of wiggle room for extras, so maybe because of that, I’ve become a pretty smart cookie when it comes to shopping wisely.  

These days, that means that I buy a lot of clothes from church thrift stores that work just fine for running errands around my little town.  A few years back, I even scored an older-but-works-great Mr. Coffee coffeemaker for free from a recycle email group. 

Heck, when my now-17-year-old daughter was in diapers, her gear came mostly from a sweet consignment store called Bearly Used (if you think that the shop’s mascot was a smiling, powder blue grizzly, you’d be right).

Being this sort of sensible buyer doesn’t mean, however, that I’m cheap.

I make it a rule to buy good shoes because they last longer; I also know they won’t give me bunions and blisters.  I make sure, too, that our honey is local and organic, as well as most of the meat, veggies and fruit we eat.  And when it comes to big purchases like a new couch, I’ll always go with American made, because even though I know I’ll be paying more than I would with an imported model, I also know the quality will be worth it.   

So, it pains me to make this confession:  I got snookered last month.

To say I am irritated with myself is an understatement—especially because what happened is all my fault.

It began with a vacuum cleaner. 

Now, this is an expensive model—my husband paid many hundreds of dollars for this sleek, forest green canister shortly after our marriage.  Over the last decade, it has been a solid work horse, even in the hands of a reckless teenager.  There have been a few repairs, but once the wand gave out—that overhaul alone would have set us back $400, with no guarantee—we both decided that a new canister (we prefer them over upright models) was in order. 

So, like every good consumer these days, I began with some online research. 

Soon enough, I found a name brand under $100.  Wow!  Not only that, but this model was deemed one of the top three vacuums in its class in 2014.  Wow again!  Reading on, a cornucopia of rapturous users described the machine’s merits, with one even saying her husband only let her buy this vacuum.  But for me, the cherry that topped the cake was this: this amazing canister, said so many beyond-satisfied users, was particularly amazing when it came to gobbling up pet hair.  Given that we have three big dogs, two of whom shed hair every single day in every single room, this vacuum seemed perfect.

I felt even smarter when I found the vacuum for $71.  Wow for the third time!  

Then the vacuum arrived. 

The box felt so… light.  Upon opening, I saw that while it WAS a canister, its body was made of cheap plastic.  With growing dismay, I also noted that the wand had no beater bar—a major design omission that has left most of our dogs’ hair still firmly embedded in our carpets.  There’s more: the coil that connects the machine to the wand is so thin and badly engineered that it actually twists up (imagine a cheap garden hose) while vacuuming.  I could go on, and I will… instead of four wheels, there are only two. And while there is a 20-foot cord, as promised, it is not retractable, but instead has to be wound around, over and over and over and OVER, to the bottom of the cleaner.

Basically, I’ve just thrown $71 to the wind—and still don’t have a working vacuum.

What have I learned?

For starters, why did I so blindly believe all of these users?  Who’s to say that the company didn’t pay them for their comments?  Who’s to say that they aren’t stockholders in said company?   Who’s to say that their pets aren’t hairless cats?  

I also made the even more terrible mistake of not checking out this vacuum in person.  Photos on the web site obviously didn’t cut it here.  In the company’s favor, I was so excited by the too-good-to-be-true price of a name brand canister that I merrily skimmed through the pictures, and skipped the crucial step of seeing the machine for myself.

What else have I learned?

Well, despite my sweet tooth for bargains, I will buy my next vacuum the way I buy my shoes.  

This time, I will go to a local dealer, one who specializes in another sort of vacuum—the high-end and dependable brand—which starts in the $400 range.  This time, I will not only see and touch and hear the machine with my own eyes, I’ll get to try it out.  Many reviews on many websites (yes, I still went online!) say that this particular brand has not only been around for decades, but that its canister models last for many, many years. 

It’s comforting, too, to know that the dealer in question has been in his same little corner shop for many years. We’ll start budgeting now.     

You can fool me once, name-brand crappy canister.  But there won’t be a next time… at least when it comes to vacuum cleaners.  

What about you?  Have you ever been fooled by something—or perhaps someone—too good to be true?  Tell me about it, and maybe I won’t feel so awful!   

36 Comments
Larry Grant
3/14/2015 10:26:43 am

I agree with everything said here. I'll never buy an "as seen on tv" anything ever again. That was my "snookered" experience. It worked on the tv ad but I think it was trick photography.

Reply
Hilary
3/14/2015 10:45:26 am

This is from my hubby. He tells me the product was a kink-free garden hose... and the first time he turned it on, the thing exploded. No returns--because the 800 number had been cancelled when he called!

Reply
Glenn Young
3/14/2015 11:59:05 pm

Eureka is a cheap and cheaply made brand. I had one years ago, and my dust mites would laugh at me since it didn't have much suction power. I currently have a Bosch canister and have loved it --- quiet, retractable cord, and great (adjustable) suction power. Miele is another good reliable brand.

Reply
Hilary
3/15/2015 03:21:46 am

I tried to cover up the brand, but I couldn't get the cord or the wand or the dog to cooperate! Interesting that you mention Miele--that is the brand that the local dealer carries, along with Royal.

Reply
leslie spoon
3/15/2015 01:25:19 am

Hilary I did that for years on irons. I would buy a cheap one at the market or drug store. They would last about 1 year. About 2 years ago I finally bought a good Blacker & Decker Classic. It costs some money but it will last a long time. I could also go on about the boyfriends who conned me but I will save that for another time!

Reply
Hilary
3/15/2015 03:23:13 am

I think all of us once in Dating Land have had one of those cons. Hmmmm, maybe an idea for another blog post? :)

Reply
Heather
3/15/2015 10:19:42 am

I certainly did. I ordered new headphones for our mini-van. The two that came with the car have been destroyed. I settled for an ebayer saying that the "universal" headphones would be great and that they specifically worked for our vehicle. They were full of static and picked up signal and static when other cars went by with a similar system. I so knew better than to think saving this money would actually work. !@#$%

Reply
Hilary
3/15/2015 02:37:44 pm

Terrible! I hope you gave the appropriate feedback to the Ebayer who sold them to you!

Reply
Fran Phinney
3/16/2015 12:04:34 pm

Forgot to mention, i did get a good deal on a new vacuum cleaner in Florida...and have since met some nice people and kindly fixit guys who live close by and are in no hurry to get paid. Wish I'd met them first!

Reply
Keith Cornell
3/16/2015 01:03:22 pm

I just spent the weekend in Las Vegas, a town where EVERYthing is too good to be true!

Reply
Hilary Grant
3/16/2015 02:22:49 pm

Ha! Of course, that's exactly what Bugsy Siegel had in mind from Day One!

Reply
Karen
3/16/2015 01:41:38 pm

We have a Dyson, in fact we have two. Canister which is called an Animal because it picks up animal hair so well. Less than $350. We also got their cordless, which is great for short clean ups. I highly recommend them. The best dishwasher I have ever had is a Meile BTW. I think one has to consider that you often get what you pay for. Getting high quality appliances has meant for us that they last and don't require replacing as often.
We all get taken. What is that saying if it looks too good to be true it probably is!
Your broader issue about being snookered makes me think about how I (we) have been snookered into giving away our privacy in the digital world. All those "free" apps I greedily downloaded when I first entered computer land, collected data on me for years, and probably you too. I was ashamed to see that my usual questioning about why you are giving me something for free, was buried under the "look, a bright shiny object" appeal of the offering.
Ya live and learn.

Reply
Hilary
3/16/2015 02:29:09 pm

We went to the vacuum store mentioned in the blog today, and I'm sold on a Royal canister. Yes, I tried it and LOVED it. Around the same price as the Dyson. And re: all of those "free" apps, I'm with ya, sista! :)

Reply
Cynthia
3/17/2015 01:07:49 am

Hilary, over here on the east coast I'm shopping for a vacuum! Checked Consumer Reports and have been online researching. Got to be able to pick up pet hair! We live in parallel worlds (but we knew that, didn't we?).

So I currently own a Kenmore Progressive which gets high marks BUT mine has needed repairs constantly and that is not uncommon with quite a few owners! So I'm considering Miele but can't decide which model. It seems the pet hair model is no better than other Miele models for the same need. Of course I always read the 1 & 2 star reviews and get worried I'm making the wrong choice all over again. However when the positives outweigh negatives significantly and there are 100's of reviews it starts to look better.

Miele doesn't seem to have very good customer service but we too have a Vacuum Guy store that repairs all vacs and sells Miele. Have not seen any Royals, but I'll look into it. Also, I owned a Simplicity for about 20 years; it has been solid and reliable, but has seen better days. Yet that brand doesn't show up in the reviews.....


Keep the comments coming. I believe in getting the best you can afford when it comes to household tools and projects -- vacuum, iron, sewing machine, electric hand sander, paint, paintbrushes, etc. etc. (Can't you return the Eureka??).

Reply
Hilary
3/17/2015 02:54:58 am

Yes, we are in parallel universes!
The Miele gets high marks but when you DO need to get it repaired, it is very expensive. Check out the Royal. I like the two-year warranty for both labor and repair. The fact that our vacuum guy sells this brand, and has been here for years, is a huge clue that this is a good vacuum. RE: returning the Eureka, I got it from the Amazon warehouse and I *have* already used it a few times. I am going to try and sell it locally as a small vacuum that's great for cleaning out your car and for little clean-ups for $20. Believe me, I've learned my lesson! But take note: the vacuum guy here says they are pretty much all made in China now.

Reply
Cynthia
3/17/2015 03:35:32 am

Just realized I never really addressed the "snookered" aspect of your original post. Will have to ponder that.

Hilary
3/17/2015 04:28:42 am

Yup, that feeling of getting taken advantage of. If I had known what the vacuum was REALLY like, and not taken all of those recommendations to heart, as well as the article that placed it in the top vacuum of 2014, I wouldn't be so pissed at myself! :)

Reply
kerri fisher
3/20/2015 02:43:44 am

Have you ever "yelp"ed someone? I just did so recently. I only wish I would remember to check Yelp out BEFORE going for a service, etc. I checked out a few of my favorite and least favorite businesses on Yelp, and the ratings were fairly accurate in my opinion.

Reply
Hilary
3/20/2015 01:10:57 pm

Yup, I've used Yelp but pretty much always for restaurants. I, too, have found the reviews to be pretty accurate. Also for hotels (some I've stayed away from because of Yelp)... I did, too, once *post* a negative comment about my former dentist. Glad I did! :)

George link
3/17/2015 10:46:21 am

I was born in Brooklyn. I've got a healthy dose of street smarts, so thankfully have never been conned. As far as vacuum cleaners go, I got a "D" brand years ago. Cost me $500. Everyone says I should have my head examined. But this thing has worked consistently for man years now and shows no sign of fading. I've always had dogs and this thing takes up dog hairs beautifully. One of the best investments I've made.

Reply
Hilary
3/17/2015 11:58:33 am

Doesn't it feel good to know that you made the right choice, even if others thought you were nuts at the time?

Reply
Bev Praver link
3/17/2015 01:00:01 pm

We had a Kirby for more than 20 years and it was still working when we got rid of it because it was too heavy to use on all the steps in the house we have now. It's major drawback was the belt always needed replacing, not hard to do or expensive but annoyingly frequent.

When we replaced it we did a lot of research and one of the questions we always asked was "Which vacuum needs the most repairs?" We were leaning toward the Meile because the belt has steel in it and it won't break. So we asked what kind of repairs they get Meile's back in the shop for and universally the answer was "I don't know. We've never had one come in." So we invested about $700 in a Meile. It's been great. We've had it for about 15 years. We did have to replace the power head after a few years but never since then. That was rather pricey. We ordered it through the vacuum shop in Los Osos. We also had a problem when the girl who was cleaning our house dropped it down the steps and broke the part that connects the hose to the body. Other than that no problems. The bags are rather pricey, but the vacuum does a great job even when our daughter brings her constantly shedding dog to visit.

Reply
Hilary
3/17/2015 01:26:00 pm

I had a reconditioned Kirby when I lived in West Hollywood--but it was very heavy and an upright... I seem to recall having to buy more than few belts as well... ultimately, not the vacuum for me. Hey, I'm going through the Los Osos vacuum guy to get our Royal, which will be in the $400 range. I tried it out at the shop and LOVED it. The fact that you ordered the Miele through the same shop tells me that the shop has been there for a good 15 years, which is really good to know!

Reply
Bev Praver
3/18/2015 03:38:36 pm

Actually I bought the Meile at a shop up north in Walnut Creek. I bought my replacement parts at the Los Osos shop.

Rebecca Galloway
3/17/2015 01:39:05 pm

I got fooled into a cheap ($6) clock that I never used because it didn't work. What seemed cheap was actually a total waste of money. I'm with you on the shoes. I mostly buy Naot now (Israeli) and they are practical and last a long time.
-- Becky

Reply
Hilary
3/17/2015 02:37:22 pm

Your second sentence says it all! I will have to check out those shoes, too! :)

Reply
Nancy Shaw
3/21/2015 05:39:08 pm

The best and most long lived pair of shoes I ever owned was Naot! I had a pair that I wore weekly, frequently daily for almost 8 years! I LOVED those shoes! I did have the heal replaced twice. I bought another pair at an expensive podiatry shoe store about a year and a half ago but then felt bad because I wanted to boycott Israel for the devastating actions against the Palestinian people (this is not about religion but about the government/military of Israel) but I forgot while finding the Naot brand and remembering the great shoes I had previously from that company. My newer pair is very cute, not quite as comfy as my first Naot's but you can tell, high quality. I also bought a pair of Clark's which I love.

Reply
kerri
3/18/2015 07:52:31 am

Boy were we snookered recently at work... We had a temp not show up to fill in for our warehouseman, which really strapped us for the day. Turned out he was busy holding up another business.... I saw his mug shot and story on the news later that night!

Reply
Hilary
3/18/2015 01:56:29 pm

Well, at least now he has three squares and a cot! What I wonder if how the temp agency did its vetting... hm.

Reply
JACKIE CAPEWELL
3/18/2015 08:14:35 am

I am with you, H on buying quality instead of quantity. Don't believe the reviews on Amazon. Seems like a bunch of robots are writing those. Maybe you could start a sort of "Angie's List" with appliances, shoes, luggage, etc. and get reviews from REAL people! I may have to get a new vacuum soon. I have a Shark, which has been OK, but I don't like that the cord doesn't retract. It does maneuver around furniture legs and corners easily. Trouble is, where I live now with wide-plank bare wood floors, the grooves are somewhat deep. (The house was build in 1886). Still vacuuming up pine needles from my Christmas tree! :)

Reply
Hilary
3/18/2015 09:25:37 am

I would go to a neighborhood vacuum store -- not Sears! but a small locally owned one! -- and find out what would work best for you. Then, do what I didn't do: try it out! Miele is getting an excellent grade in these comments but it is pretty pricey. Pretty sure we'll be getting a Royal, which is in the $400 range. :)

Reply
Nancy Shaw
3/21/2015 05:31:55 pm

Hilary, my sister got a Royal from the Atascadero vacuum shop about two years ago and last time I asked her about it, she was still happy with it.

Debbie, MM link
3/19/2015 05:50:46 am

Great stuff Hilary, there is nothing worse than being excited and believing you have one thing coming and getting nothing like what you were promised and hoped for. YIKES! I often wonder about the reviews too as I rely on them with everything I do.

Reply
Hilary
3/19/2015 08:37:10 am

Yes, I've learned that not all reviews are created equal... and I should have KNOWN that for $71, I'd get a $71 vacuum cleaner! :)

Reply
Kevin Fagan link
3/19/2015 09:25:16 am

At this point in my life, I'm so leery of getting scammed I don't bite on anything. Last time I got hosed was when I bought "miracle restoring" paint treatment for my car hood off the TV, and it amazingly made the already crappy hood look even crappier - forever.

Reply
Hilary
3/19/2015 09:56:15 am

As two journalists who know how to research, you would think we would both know better than to bite. At least I've learned my lesson now, and I can see you've learned yours, too! :) BTW, I just sold it for $20, so I'm only out $51. I let the buyer know, too, that it wasn't heavy enough for my needs. She tested the suction, too, and it worked for her. I'm glad it now has a good home!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Hilary Roberts Grant

    Journalist, editor, filmmaker, foodie--and a clown! 
    ​

    Categories

    All
    Activism
    Blogaversaries
    Doing It Right
    Food
    Holidays
    Living Life
    Miscellany
    My Girl
    People
    Reading
    Remembering
    Taking Care
    Traveling

    Archives

    September 2025
    June 2025
    December 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    June 2023
    December 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.